Skip to main content
Bel Covo
modern sleek onyx polished concrete

Questions to ask a concrete contractor, and comparing bids

Ron Galloway

Ron Galloway

Owner, Bel CovoUpdated

The questions to ask a concrete contractor are the seven that put every bid on the same page. Ask for the slab thickness and the mix strength (3,500 PSI is the floor for a slab you plan to finish). Then ask about the steel and where it sits, the vapor barrier, the joint layout, the cure, and the finish. Get the answers in writing. Then you can line up three bids that didn’t match and see what each one buys.

Use this list on every bidder, us included.

Why do two honest bids on the same slab differ by thousands?

Because they’re two different slabs. A 40x60 shop slab in Oklahoma runs $5.32 to $15.61 per square foot installed. On those 2,400 square feet of ground, that’s $12,750 to $37,100 before the drive cost (our trip to your site). Our 40x60 slab cost page has the full range.

The low-end slab is a plain broom-finish slab, 4 inches thick, with fiber mesh in the mix instead of steel. It has no vapor barrier, and its joints get cut when someone swings back through. It gets a sprayed cure-and-seal because that’s fast, then a broom finish. Every one of those is a fair choice on a slab that holds a tractor and never gets a finished floor.

The high-end slab is 5 or 6 inches thick, built for polishing, epoxy, or heavy equipment. It has #4 rebar sitting on chairs (small stands that hold the steel up) in the upper third of the pour. A 15-mil Class A barrier lies right against the concrete. The joints follow a drawn grid and get sawed in the green window, which means early, before the slab cracks on its own. It gets a wet cure and a troweled surface made for whatever goes on top of it two years from now.

Neither bidder lied to you. They wrote down two different slabs and priced each one right. But a total at the bottom of a page hides all of that, so when you’re reading three totals side by side, you can’t tell which slab you’re looking at.

What does each step up cost?

On our quote tool, a standard broom slab starts at $5.55 a square foot. That’s with wire mesh. Swap the mesh for fiber, and you get the low end of the range above. Our SPEC shop build, with all four steps below, runs $8.42 a square foot. Each step is priced by the square foot, before setup and the drive.

  • #4 rebar on chairs. It’s set 18 inches apart, and it adds $1.49 over wire mesh.
  • A 15-mil Class A vapor barrier. It adds $0.60 over no barrier.
  • The SPEC placement. That’s a 4000+ PSI mix with little water, placed flat enough to polish. It adds $0.64 over our standard pour.
  • A 7-day wet cure under plastic. It adds $0.14 over a spray-on cure.

The quote tool prices thickness too, anywhere from 3 to 10 inches. Each of those lines runs across every square foot of the slab, so on a 40x60 the gaps add up to thousands.

What are the seven scope lines every bid should name?

These seven cover the choices nobody can change after the truck leaves.

Scope lineA good answer sounds likeAn answer that should worry you
Finished thickness5 inches in the field, 6 at the drive-in apron, over 4 inches of packed base.“Standard” or “code minimum.”
Mix strength4,000 PSI, with air mixed in for outdoor work and slump held at 4 to 5.“Whatever the plant sends that morning.”
Reinforcement type and placement#4 rebar 18 inches on center, up on chairs in the top third, chairs checked after the first truck.“Rebar,” with no spacing, no depth, and no word about chairs.
Vapor barrier15-mil Class A per ASTM E1745, poly right against the slab, seams lapped 6 inches and taped per ASTM E1643.“We will roll some poly out,” or “you do not need it under a shop.”
Joint layout and timingCut on a drawn grid, sawed early before the slab cracks on its own, diagonals at every inside corner.“We cut them when we come back through.”
Cure methodWet cure under plastic and blankets for 7 days, or a dissipating compound named in writing.“It cures on its own.”
Surface finishBroom finish, or a hard trowel to a stated flatness number if the floor gets polished later.“Smooth.”

None of those answers costs a crew anything to give. A crew that pours to a spec knows the numbers. They’ll rattle them off faster than you can write them down. A bidder who can’t name a thickness and a PSI priced the square feet and guessed at the rest.

How do you turn three bids into one comparison?

Write your own scope sheet. It’s one page and seven lines, with your numbers in the blanks. Send the same sheet to all three bidders and ask each one to price it again.

  1. Fill in the seven lines yourself first, based on what the building has to do. A shop that parks a loaded gooseneck isn’t a patio.
  2. Send the same sheet to each bidder. Use the same paper and the same words, with no side notes by phone like “I also told him that…”
  3. Ask each one to bid again against the sheet, and to flag anything on it they’d change and why. A bidder who tells you 6 inches is overkill for a mower shed is doing you a favor.
  4. Lay the three new bids side by side.

Now a price gap means something. Before that, picking the low number is just a guess.

Two items that go missing and come back as change orders

Two things go missing more than all the rest put together: a pump truck and imported fill.

A pump truck. A pump is an option for reach, not a default. You need one when a mixer truck can’t get close enough to unload into the pour. That might be a back corner, a tight drive, a septic field a loaded truck can’t cross, or a power line over the only way in. When a site needs one, pump service runs $1,780 per pour day. Ask each bidder if his number has a pump in it. If it doesn’t, ask what he expects the truck to reach.

Imported fill (subgrade material). If the pad sits low, or the dirt won’t pack down and stay put, someone hauls dirt in and rolls it. A laser level can measure how much before anyone bids. A bidder who has walked the pad can tell you about how many loads he’s figuring on. If a bid assumes the dirt is already right on a pad nobody has graded yet, that number is going to move.

Watch for unwritten scope

Nothing here argues against running your own build. Owner-builders write better scope sheets than most GCs, because they care more. The real risk is a slab one crew priced by phone and a second crew finished months later, with no written spec to tie them together. The finish crew is stuck with every choice the pour crew made, and it can’t change a single one. That gap is where the arguments start. A one-page scope sheet closes most of it before either crew shows up.

Three lines get stricter when the slab gets polished or coated

Flatness, the vapor barrier, and the cure all tighten up. And they tighten at bid time or not at all.

Flatness becomes a number instead of a feeling. It’s measured as FF, the floor flatness number. Most shop and store pours land around 25 to 30 on the FF scale. That passes a normal inspection, but it won’t take a high-gloss polish. Write the target into your scope sheet, then require the measurement per ASTM E1155 before any finish crew shows up. How it works, the finish levels, and the cost of fixing a low score later are all on our FF flatness score page.

The vapor barrier stops being a maybe. The plastic goes right against the bottom of the slab, with nothing that soaks up water in between. Our vapor barrier placement page shows why that one detail decides if a coating lasts.

The cure becomes a line on the spec, not an afterthought. A sprayed acrylic cure-and-seal leaves a film on top. That film keeps the densifier from soaking in, and it keeps coatings from sticking. So a slab headed for a finish wants a wet cure, or a dissipating compound (one that wears off on its own) named on paper. The Pour-4-Polish SPEC framework lays out all four pour-day steps and their limits. And if a bidder wants a source that isn’t you, point him to ACI 332, the concrete standard for homes.

How do you ask these questions without insulting the crew?

Ask about the slab, not about the man. Crews get accused of cutting corners all the time, mostly by people who’ve never poured anything. A question that sounds like a charge shuts down the very talk you need. If the questions stay on the work, a 10-minute phone call covers all seven lines.

  • “What thickness and PSI are you carrying on this?” is a question about the work.
  • “Are you going to skip the barrier like the last guy?” is about his character, and you’ll get a short answer.
  • “I’m asking all three bidders the same seven things, so nobody gets compared unfairly” turns the list into routine. Most crews relax when they hear it, because it means the low bidder can’t win on a missing line.
  • “What would you change about my scope sheet?” asks for the one thing you really want, which is his judgment.

Get the answers in writing, however the call goes. It’s not that anyone’s dishonest. The man you talked to in April will be on a different job in July, and paper doesn’t move.

What do owner-builders ask most about concrete bids?

Owner-builders ask us these 4 about concrete bids on nearly every acreage build we walk.

Do I need all seven answers before I choose?

Yes, and you need them from all three bidders. Six of seven from one and four from another puts you right back to guessing. Each line changes what the slab can do, so a missing line is a choice someone else makes for you later.

Is the low bid always the wrong bid?

No. Sometimes the low bidder priced the slab you really need, and the other two priced one you don’t. That’s exactly what the scope sheet shows you. On a mower shed, 4 inches with fiber and a broom finish is the right answer. Paying for a polish-ready pour there is money set on fire.

Should I have a contractor with me when I ask?

No. Ask them yourself, one bidder at a time, and keep your own notes. Bring one contractor to judge another’s bid, and you get a biased read and lose the honest talk. The seven lines are plain enough that anyone can hear a real answer.

What if a bidder refuses to put the spec in writing?

Then the spec isn’t settled, and you have your answer. A bidder who won’t put a thickness and a mix strength in writing is telling you those numbers can still change after the check clears. Give the job to a bidder who will put the spec on paper.

One page beats three totals

Three bids at three prices are three opinions until someone writes down what the slab is. Seven lines on one page does that. Writing them takes maybe 20 minutes, and sending the sheet out and reading the three new bids fills out the afternoon.

If a builder or a GC runs your slab as a sub job, the same seven lines go in that contract. Our builder and GC page covers how we write the pour and the finish as one spec, not two.

Put a fourth number on the same sheet

Our quote tool prices most of these lines: how thick, what steel, the vapor barrier, the mix, and the cure. Hold our number next to the three you have.

Related project photos

Completed exterior concrete parking area with control joints next to commercial buildingLarge freshly poured and floated exterior concrete slab next to commercial buildingFreshly poured exterior concrete slab being finished outside commercial buildingPolished concrete floor in luxury home entryway reflecting chandelier and modern interior designAction Powersports custom logo embedded in glossy black epoxy showroom floorGuthrie Round Barn polished concrete floor with mirror-like reflections of windows in dark high-gloss finish

Frequently asked questions

What questions should I ask a concrete contractor before signing anything?

Ask seven: finished slab thickness, mix strength in PSI, the type of steel and where it sits in the pour, vapor barrier thickness and position, the joint layout and when the joints get cut, the cure method, and the surface finish. Ask every bidder the same seven, and get the answers in writing. Until those seven are on paper, the totals at the bottom of three bids aren't describing the same slab, so you can't compare them.

Why is one concrete bid thousands of dollars cheaper than another?

Usually because it's a different slab. A 40x60 shop slab in Oklahoma runs $5.32 to $15.61 per square foot installed. The low end buys a 4-inch broom-finish utility slab. The high end buys a 5 or 6 inch pour built for polishing, epoxy, or heavy equipment, with rebar on chairs and a Class A vapor barrier under it. Both numbers can be honest. The gap is scope, and you can't see scope in a total.

Should I send the same scope sheet to every bidder?

Yes. It's the most useful thing you can do on a slab without hiring anyone. Write your own one-page scope with thickness, PSI, steel, barrier, joints, cure, and finish filled in. Send it to all three bidders and ask each one to price it again. That costs an afternoon. It turns three bids built on three different guesses into three prices for one slab.

What is usually missing from a concrete bid?

Two items go missing more than any others: a pump truck and imported fill. A pump is an option for reach, when a mixer truck can't get close enough to the pour. When a site needs one, it runs $1,780 per pour day. Imported fill shows up when the pad sits low or the native soil won't pack down. Both can be measured before anyone bids, and both turn into change orders when nobody asks.

How do I ask about the spec without insulting a crew I might hire?

Ask about the slab, not about the crew. 'What thickness and PSI are you carrying?' is a question about the work. 'Are you cutting corners?' is a question about the man. Good crews answer spec questions fast, because the answers are already in their head. Tell every bidder up front that you're asking all three the same list. That makes the questions procedure, not suspicion.

Does a concrete bid have to name a PSI?

It should. PSI is the strength the batch plant designs the mix to reach. It drives how dense and hard the surface gets, and how the slab takes a finish later. A slab meant for polished concrete or a resin coating wants 3,500 PSI as a floor. A bid that just says 'concrete' leaves the mix choice to whoever answers the phone at the plant on pour day.

Ready to transform your floors?

Get a free, no-obligation quote for your concrete flooring project.